A reporter for Science Alert indicated that the world's oldest known water was found in an ancient pool below [Note: groundwater does not occur in "pools," below the surface. It does occur in the porous media of rocks or in fractures and joints in very old rocks] Canada in 2016, and is at least 2 billion years old. Back in 2013 scientists found water dating back about 1.5 billion years at the Kidd Mine in Ontario, but in 2016, deeper investigation revealed an even older source buried underground tunnel. The initial discovery of the ancient liquid in 2013 came at a depth of around 2.4 kilometers (1.5 miles) in an underground tunnel in the mine [Note: There is nothing unusual about encountering groundwater at such depths]. But the extreme depth of the mine – which at 3.1 kilometers (1.9 miles) is the deepest base metal mine in the world – gave researchers the opportunity to keep digging. "[The 2013 find] really pushed back our understanding of how old flowing water could be and so it really drove us to explore further," geochemist Barbara Sherwood Lollar from the University of Toronto told Rebecca Morelle at the BBC back in 2016.[Note: Sampling of deep groundwater would be of interest nonetheless]
"And we took advantage of the fact that the mine is continuing to explore deeper and deeper into the earth." The 2016 source was found at about 3 kilometers (1.9 miles) down, and according to Sherwood Lollar, there's a lot more of it than you might expect. "When people think about this water they assume it must be some tiny amount of water trapped within the rock," she said. [Note: Only ignorant people would think that, but hydrogeologists would not]. "But in fact it's very much bubbling right up out at you. These things are flowing at rates of liters per minute – the volume of the water is much larger than anyone anticipated."[Note: The flow is not higher than expected .....] Groundwater usually flows extremely slowly compared to surface water – as slowly as 1 meter per year. But when tapped with boreholes drilled in the mine, it can flow at about 2 liters per minute.[Note: That flow rate is not unusual].
By analyzing gases dissolved in this ancient groundwater – including helium, neon, argon, and xenon – the researchers were able to date it back to at least 2 billion years, making it the oldest known water on Earth. The findings were presented in December 2016 at the American Geophysical Union Fall Meeting in San Francisco. In previous research that the team published in October, analysis of the sulfate content of the water found at 2.4 km down showed something interesting – that the sulfate was produced in situ in a chemical reaction between the water and the rock, and not the result of sulfate being carried underground by surface water. [Note: another nothing new burger here]
This means that the geochemical conditions in these ancient "pools" of water that are cut off from the surface could be sufficient in themselves to sustain microbial life – an independent, underground ecosystem that could last for potentially billions of years. [Note: another nothing new burger here. The writer(s) need to get better technical support to avoid writing this BS].
"The wow factor is high," one of the researchers, Long Li from the University of Alberta, said in a press release. "If geological processes can naturally supply a steady energy source in these rocks, the modern terrestrial subsurface biosphere may expand significantly both in breadth and depth." Not only does that mean Earth's potentially habitable areas could be a whole lot bigger – given comparable billion-year-old rocks make up about half of Earth's continental crust – it could also mean that planetary habitability on other worlds might be wider than we thought. [Note: Who thought? Another nothing new burger here. The writer(s) need to get better technical support to avoid writing this BS].
"If this can work on ancient rocks on Earth, then similar processes could make the Martian subsurface habitable," Sherwood Lollar explained to Hannah Fung at The Varsity back in 2016. While we haven't found any actual living microbes in this ancient underground water yet – on Earth or anywhere else for that matter – with the more ancient pools we find, the closer we could get. [Note: Forget "pools," the groundwater will be present in fractures and joints in old rocks and will make "pools" on the floor of mine shafts having been recharged from the surface a long time ago, but getting accurate dates could be tricky].
But There's a Lot More Research to be Done.
"We still need to determine what the distribution of ancient waters are on Earth, what the ages of this deep hydrogeosphere are, how many are inhabited," said Sherwood Lollar. [Of course, but conducted by hydrogeologist who know about matters, not by academics who know very little about the nature of groundwater flow]
"[A]nd how any life we might find in those isolated waters is the same or different from other microbial life found for instance at the hydrothermal vents on the ocean floors." [Note: of course this is an analogy and another nothing new burger here]
[Note: The factual problems in the article is due to poor editorial oversight, which should have edited out the BS in the article]
Managed & Built by I2M Consulting, LLC | © 2010-
